The jury trial in Commonwealth v. Patrick Roy Vereb was canceled on October 15, the day jury selection was set to begin. WTAE, citing court documents, reported the cancellation, and the attorneys in the case confirmed the new direction to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Vereb now plans to plead guilty to all 10 counts against him at a hearing scheduled for October 22, 2026, at 10 a.m. in Courtroom 316 of the Allegheny County Courthouse.
The Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office said Vereb's counsel "notified the court that he is expected to plead guilty to all criminal charges on October 22, 2026."
Get the Tuesday Deathcare Briefing
Who’s buying whom in deathcare — free, once a week.
The cancellation unwinds the schedule Obitley reported on September 22, which had jury selection starting October 15 and trial openings before Common Pleas Judge Jaime Hickton on October19.
Vereb, 70 according to the Attorney General's Office, is the former owner of Eternity Pet Memorials in Hazelwood. Prosecutors charged him on April 28, 2025 with 10 felony counts: one count of theft by deception, one count of receiving stolen property, and eight counts of deceptive business practices. Receiving stolen property means holding or dealing in goods the holder knows were stolen. Deceptive business practices counts accuse a business owner of misleading customers about the services being sold.
The Attorney General's investigation identified more than 6,500 victims across Allegheny, Armstrong, Washington, and Westmoreland counties. Prosecutors say Vereb collected at least $657,517 between 2021 and 2024 from pet owners promised private cremations for their animals. Customers who paid received ashes from other, unknown animals.
The landfill receipts show where the pets went. Eternity sold two services: private cremation, where a pet is cremated individually and the ashes returned to the owner, and common burial, where pets are buried together at a pet cemetery. Vereb told investigators he hadn't used local pet cemeteries "in a while," and his records listed just under 500 pets, weighing roughly 27,000 pounds, as slated for common burial during the period investigators analyzed. Landfill receipts for that same period showed more than 170,000 pounds of animals discarded. That is more than six times the weight of the burial bookings. The difference was the pets sold private cremations. At least 6,500 of them were never cremated, according to the charges, and when a cremation "took too long," Vereb told investigators, he handed owners ashes he had on hand "to make them feel good for the day if nothing else."
The scheduled plea is an open plea. Vereb would admit guilt to every count with no agreed sentence attached. The AG's case page puts it in plain terms: "There is no agreement as to the sentence on this charge." The AG's Office told WPXI the lack of a sentence agreement means it does not view this as a plea deal. Judge Hickton will set the sentence on the lead charge, theft by deception, a first-degree felony. The sentencing guidelines the AG cites for that charge run from house arrest up to more than a year in jail.
Sentencing will come later. The court will first order a presentence investigation, a report on the defendant's background that judges rely on when shaping a sentence. The Post-Gazette reports sentencing will likely happen early next year. No sentencing date has been set.
In court on Thursday, Senior Deputy Attorney General Kara Rice said restitution is expected upward of $600,000, and per the Post-Gazette her office will seek probation on the deceptive business practices counts in light of the restitution. Rice is prosecuting the case with Deputy Attorney General Aaron McKendry. Louis Emmi represents Vereb.
Victims still have a path to be heard. The AG's Office says it has compiled every victim impact statement submitted through its website and will provide them to the judge and defense counsel for sentencing. Because more than 6,500 victims have been identified and courtroom space is limited, the AG has asked for written statements. Judge Hickton said court officials will work to figure out a way to accommodate the large number of pet owners who might want to offer victim impact statements, the Post-Gazette reports. Anyone who already submitted a statement needs to do nothing further. The AG will request that Vereb be ordered to pay restitution as part of his final sentence.
The case began with a whistleblower. Tiffany Mantzouridis, a licensed funeral director and former intern at the funeral home, went to police, and her information sparked the Attorney General's investigation, WPXI and WTAE report. A class action filed in May 2025 separately alleges ashes of larger animals were divided into smaller portions and passed off to owners of smaller pets.
The case also carries separate, uncharged allegations about human remains. Two former employees of Vereb Funeral Home allege he mishandled human remains at the Hazelwood funeral home, and both told WPXI's 11 Investigates they sat for hours of interviews with a state investigator. Vereb has never been charged in relation to those allegations.
What to watch on October 22: the plea hearing starts at 10 a.m. in Courtroom 316 of the Allegheny County Courthouse. Vereb is expected to plead guilty to all criminal charges. Sentencing will be scheduled for a later date after the presentence investigation. Victims can submit impact statements through the AG's portal at attorneygeneral.gov/epm, and the AG says it will publish sentencing details once the court sets them.
*Obitley will update this article after the October 22 plea hearing.*
*Sources: Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General "Eternity Pet Memorials" case page (accessed October 16, 2026); Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General press release, April 28, 2025; Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, October 15, 2026; WTAE, October 15, 2026; WPXI/11 Investigates, October 15, 2026.*
Get investigations like this in your inbox
Free. Every Tuesday.