Issue #10 · September 15, 2026

A Simple Majority and a Ballot That Opens Before the Plan; Chicago Seeks $11,500 a Day; 14 Suits Pile Up on TruStage; Two States Write New Rules

Selected's CEO told Obitley the merger vote needs only a simple majority, and the electronic ballot opens September 24, days before the opposition's alternative plan is expected. Chicago sued the South Chicago Chapel operators for $11,500 a day over 23 code violations, 14 class actions now target TruStage over the cyberattack that left preneed policies unverifiable, and Colorado and Texas both put new deathcare rules on the books. This issue covers two weeks of Obitley investigations.

By Heidi Macomber, Founder, Obitley

The ballot opens September 24. The opposition's alternative plan is due September 28 to October 5.

On a September 14 program published by On Deathcare, host Tony Russo described a statement from Selected's leadership: anyone considering voting no on the sale to the NFDA "should have a well-researched plan that they're willing to present." Russo then pointed at one of his own panelists, Nathanael Billow, the sixth-generation Ohio funeral director organizing the opposition. Billow's response, as Russo told it, was "okay, I've got one and I'm going to present it to you." More material, Russo said, would be out "probably in the next two or three weeks."

The calendar is the problem. The electronic ballot opens September 24 and closes October 8, per the written update Selected's communications firm sent Obitley on September 11. Per the program's September 14 publication, two to three weeks puts the opposition's plan at September 28 to October 5. Under the earliest estimate, the plan arrives four days after voting begins. Under the latest, it comes three days before voting ends.

The vote threshold moved this month as well, and the correction came in an on-record Obitley interview. In a September 9 telephone interview, Selected CEO Rob Paterkiewicz said the merger ballot requires a simple majority, not the two-thirds supermajority described in trade coverage since August 20. The ballot is a vote to dissolve the association under D.C. nonprofit law, because Selected cannot remain a separate 501(c)(6) if the two organizations combine. "It is not a two-thirds, it actually is a simple majority vote," Paterkiewicz said.

Seven named critics appeared on the September 14 program. What members are voting on remains a letter of intent that legal counsel for both organizations has told members is confidential and cannot be shared with them. The ballot question now runs against a clock: 15 days of voting, with the opposition's case for an alternative arriving in the middle of it.

Source: Obitley reporting, September 9 and September 15, 2026. On-record telephone interview with Selected CEO Rob Paterkiewicz, September 9, 2026. Written update from Selected's communications firm to Obitley, September 11, 2026. On Deathcare program published September 14, 2026.


Consolidation

Not two-thirds: Selected's CEO says the merger vote needs only a simple majority

Trade coverage since August 20, Obitley's included, described the threshold as a two-thirds supermajority of the membership. In a September 9 telephone interview, Rob Paterkiewicz, Selected's CEO and executive director since 2007, said the number does not apply to this vote. "It is not a two-thirds, it actually is a simple majority vote," he told Obitley.

The distinction is what kind of vote this is. Selected's constitution requires a two-thirds majority for changes to itself, and that is the figure the association has referenced for years. But the merger ballot asks members to approve the dissolution of the association, because Selected cannot remain a separate 501(c)(6) if the two organizations combine. Under D.C. nonprofit law, where Selected is incorporated, that vote requires a simple majority. D.C. Code sec. 29-412.02 governs approval of dissolution for nonprofit corporations.

Paterkiewicz said counsel raised the question "a couple of weeks ago, just prior to showing up to the annual meeting," and that the change was shared with members during the closed Annual Meeting in Louisville. The electronic ballot launches September 24 and stays open 15 days. Selected was founded in 1917 by 25 funeral firms. For opponents whose poll of 70 firms found 85 percent leaning no, the lower threshold cuts the other way: fewer yes votes are needed to end the association's independence.

Read the full investigation →

Consumer Protection

$11,500 a day: Chicago sues South Chicago Chapel's operators over 23 code violations

The City of Chicago has taken the operators of South Chicago Chapel to court, asking a Cook County judge to fine Clark and Johanna Morgan $11,500 for every day that 23 building code violations go uncorrected. The complaint, Case No. 20261401023 in the Circuit Court of Cook County, was filed in late August and reported by WTTW on September 1. It calls the business an unlicensed funeral home, and it is the city's first court action against the operators since authorities found 56 decomposing bodies in the building on August 6.

The filing describes the storage room. It says 51 bodies were stacked there in varying degrees of severe decomposition, half inside an "insufficiently operating cooler." The rest were "strewn haphazardly" through the storage area, and "the stench was overwhelming and could be smelled outside the building." The city inspected the property on August 6 and alleges the violations existed that day "and on each succeeding day thereafter." Midwest Group of Illinois, LLC, owns the building, and the Morgans and South Chicago Chapel Inc. are named as lessees. The city leaves a receiver and demolition open as remedies.

What has not happened is equally central. No criminal charges have been filed against the Morgans to date, more than a month after the discovery. The complaint's records review notes that Evergreen Park police found two bodies in Clark Morgan's minivan in June 2024, two years before the chapel discovery. A proposed class action over the chapel has a first hearing set for October 13, and the city's suit runs on a parallel track, converting each uncorrected day into money. The Cook County medical examiner had identified 47 of the 56 remains as of August 21.

Read the full investigation →

Consumer Protection

Fourteen class actions and a funeral director who cannot verify his own policies: the TruStage cyberattack six weeks on

Joe Earthman holds two TruStage preneed contracts at Joseph Earthman Generations, his Houston funeral home, and in late August he could verify neither. "We've got no idea when we're going to get paid," he told the trade publication Connecting Directors on August 25. "We haven't even been able to verify that these policies even exist."

TruStage, the insurer formerly known as CUNA Mutual Group, identified the attack on July 11, shut down its own network to contain it, and disclosed the incident publicly on July 15. It told partners it anticipated the majority of key processes would be operational by mid-August. Funeral homes are still counting the cost: Missouri families fronted funeral costs they had already paid for in advance, and 14 proposed class actions are now pending in federal court, including one brought by a credit union, Bessemer System FCU.

TruStage says it protects 42 million consumer relationships, and 93 percent of credit unions partner with the insurer, because of its historic roots in the credit union movement. The insurer's first court answer is due September 24.

Read the full investigation →

Consumer Protection

A rod in the ground confirmed it: burial mix-ups at Everstory-linked cemeteries become a federal class action

Two Wake Forest parents lost their son in March 2021 and buried his remains at Pine Forest Memorial Gardens, then bought two additional plots beside him so they could be buried at his feet. Four years later, on a gravesite visit, they found what appeared to be "another body" in the plot they owned, according to the lawsuit. A cemetery employee then "placed a rod in the ground and confirmed again that someone was buried there," the complaint states, in wording reported by WRAL.

The case, Foster v. Pine Forest Memorial Gardens LLC, No. 5:26-cv-00620, now sits before Judge Louise W. Flanagan in the Eastern District of North Carolina as a proposed federal class action, and the docket moved from removal to mediation in three days. WRAL identifies the cemetery's corporate ownership as Everstory Partners, a Florida-based operator with more than 400 cemeteries across 23 states and Puerto Rico, including 58 operations in North Carolina, second only to Pennsylvania.

The state record shows the same pattern in slow motion. North Carolina Cemetery Commission files show 30 complaints against Montlawn, an Everstory cemetery, since 2020, and no formal action taken. In 2014, Kizzie Sewell paid $3,150 for a Montlawn gravesite that turned out to be double-sold; her husband was exhumed in 2019 under a court order. WRAL counts the Pine Forest suit as at least the second such mix-up at Montlawn and the third involving an Everstory property.

Read the full investigation →

Regulatory

One registration, one expiration date: Colorado converts every funeral home and crematory on a three-month fuse

Colorado's Office of Funeral and Mortuary Science Services adopted the first phase of rules implementing HB26-1258 on an emergency basis on August 31, at a hearing that began at 3:30 p.m. Mountain time. The same day, every funeral home and crematory registration in the state converted to a single "Funeral Establishment" registration, prefix FES. "Funeral Home and Crematory Applications are no longer available," the state's licensing portal states.

The conversion came with a deadline attached. Every FES registration in Colorado, converted ones included, expires November 30, 2026, putting every funeral establishment in the state up for renewal at once, ahead of the 2027 individual-licensure requirement. Funeral Establishment applications opened September 1.

The emergency rules cover only the first half of the bill signed in June; the second half has no date. Under the law itself, abuse of a corpse rises to a class 5 felony on January 1, 2027 for offenses committed on or after that date, and the registration program and individual licenses face sunset review together in September 2031.

Read the full investigation →

Regulatory

Chain of custody on paper: Texas writes operating rules for its body-donation industry

Texas's new operating rules for willed body programs and anatomical donation took effect September 6. The Texas Funeral Service Commission adopted the package August 14 and published it in the Texas Register on August 28, amending 22 Texas Administrative Code Chapter 206 to give the commission operating rules for the programs Senate Bill 2040 moved to the agency in 2023.

The rules apply when a death certificate's disposition reads "Donation" or when a non-transplant anatomical donation organization is the donee. They bring chain-of-custody forms, registration for donation organizations on 12-month terms, and an admission ban on public display, with chain-of-custody form enforcement beginning October 6 and custody forms retained for seven years.

The same Register issue repeals the rules of the Anatomical Board of the State of Texas, the defunct board whose separate regulatory role ended in 2023, with the commission as successor agency. Obitley previously traced who profits in the body-donation industry and how unevenly states regulate it.

Read the full investigation →

Regulatory

Only three left: Oklahoma's funeral-director casket monopoly clears its first court test

Oklahoma County District Judge Don Andrews denied the state's motion to dismiss on July 30, keeping alive Caskets of Honor's constitutional challenge to the Funeral Services Licensing Act, the law that reserves casket sales for licensed funeral directors. Oklahoma is one of three states with such a ban, per the Institute for Justice. The case now moves to a full hearing on the merits. No hearing date has been reported in any public source.

Candice Mentink and Todd Collard run Caskets of Honor from Calvin, in Hughes County, selling caskets wrapped in vinyl graphic designs. In 2021 the couple displayed caskets at the Tulsa State Fair, where a Funeral Board investigator posed undercover as an interested customer. The Board fined them $4,000, per the petition, and sought more than $8,000 before the couple settled for $4,700 in fines and costs. They now sell only to funeral homes, and the Board required a workshop sign stating they cannot sell directly to their fellow Oklahomans. Reorganized as a Texas company, the business ships to almost every state except Oklahoma.

The license path, per the suit: two years of mortuary science classes, a one-year apprenticeship, and two exams. The 10th U.S. Circuit upheld the law under the U.S. Constitution in Powers v. Harris (2004); the new suit runs under the Oklahoma Constitution. The state called the law consumer protection; the petition cites the Board's own consumer FAQ: "there is no direct relationship between the protective features of the casket and the preservation of the body." Repeal bills died in three straight sessions, with the Funeral Board and the state funeral directors association the only reported opponents. An expert report filed in the suit by economist David Harrington puts the average Oklahoma funeral at $5,671, 18 percent above neighboring states, a figure not independently verified.

Read the full investigation →

Courts

Forty-three charges dismissed, $266,636 sought: Nebraska headstone fraud case moves to September 30 sentencing

Kelli Lepler pleaded no contest on August 4 in Hall County District Court to three Class IIIA felony counts of attempted theft by deception, and Judge Andrew Butler found her guilty. In exchange, 43 theft charges were dismissed. Sentencing is set for 1:30 p.m. on September 30. The plea followed a year-and-a-half competency fight: Butler found her not competent to stand trial in January 2025, ordered her medicated in July 2025, and ruled her competent in June 2026. She had spent 1,118 days in custody, from her July 2023 arrest in Wentzville, Missouri, to the plea.

The money owed to victims is one open question. The State will request full restitution of $266,636.28, with the exact amount set at sentencing. Terri Webben, a retired Grand Island teacher, paid Lepler $7,510 in August 2021 for a headstone for her husband; two years of excuses followed before a police complaint in April 2023, and a replacement stone cost $6,766 more. Victims told Central Nebraska Today they doubt Lepler can pay restitution.

The other open question is what the case costs Nebraska taxpayers, and Obitley ran the first accounting. At the Nebraska Association of County Officials' published 2024 jail average of $81 a day, the 1,118 days in custody already cost $90,558, and that is a floor. A nine-year prison term at the corrections department's published rate would add roughly $120,000; 15 years of probation far less. Added up, the prison path brings total taxpayer exposure to roughly $210,000 to $230,000, and the probation path to roughly $100,000 to $150,000. Prosecutors will not seek additional jail time, KSNB reported.

Read the full investigation →

On the Horizon

Stories and projects in development


By the Numbers

15 days

How long Selected's merger ballot stays open, September 24 to October 8, per the association's September 11 written update to Obitley

Simple majority

Votes needed to approve the NFDA deal and dissolve Selected, per CEO Rob Paterkiewicz; the two-thirds figure from trade coverage does not apply

$11,500/day

Fine Chicago seeks for each day that 23 building code violations at South Chicago Chapel go uncorrected

51

Bodies the city's complaint says were stacked in the rear storage room, of the 56 found on August 6

14

Proposed class actions pending against TruStage in federal court after the July cyberattack; the insurer's first answer is due September 24

93%

Share of credit unions that partner with TruStage, per American Banker, explaining the reach of the preneed outage

30

Complaints against Montlawn sitting in North Carolina Cemetery Commission files since 2020 with no formal action taken

3

States that limit casket sales to licensed funeral directors, per the Institute for Justice; Oklahoma's law survived its first court test

$266,636

Full restitution Nebraska will request from Kelli Lepler at September 30 sentencing, after 43 charges were dismissed in a plea

$90,558

Cost of Lepler's 1,118 days of pretrial custody at the state's published $81-a-day county jail average; Obitley puts total taxpayer exposure at $100,000 to $230,000

Nov. 30, 2026

Date every Colorado Funeral Establishment registration expires, converted ones included, ahead of 2027 individual licensure


From Obitley This Week

9 new investigations published on obitley.com:

VOTE FIRST, PLAN LATER

Selected's ballot opens September 24, before the opposition's alternative plan is expected

NOT TWO-THIRDS

The CEO tells Obitley the merger vote needs a simple majority, not the two-thirds in trade coverage

$11,500 A DAY

Chicago sues South Chicago Chapel's operators over 23 code violations, in a complaint describing 51 bodies in a rear storage room

PAID ON FAITH

The TruStage cyberattack leaves preneed funeral policies unverifiable as 14 class actions pile up

A STRANGER IN THE FAMILY PLOT

A federal class action follows burial mix-ups at Everstory-linked North Carolina cemeteries, with 30 complaints and no formal state action

ONE REGISTRATION, ONE DEADLINE

Colorado converts every funeral home and crematory to a single registration that expires November 30

CHAIN OF CUSTODY ON PAPER

Texas writes operating rules for its body-donation industry, with enforcement beginning October 6

ONLY THREE LEFT

Oklahoma's funeral-director casket monopoly clears its first court test and heads to a merits hearing

CONVICTED IN HEADSTONE FRAUD

Kelli Lepler faces September 30 sentencing, $266,636 in restitution sought, and a taxpayer bill already past $90,000

Read all investigations at obitley.com/stories →


The Weekly Deathcare Briefing is published every Tuesday by Obitley. If you have a tip, story idea, or correction, reply to this email.

Heidi Macomber

Founder, Obitley · obitley.com

Get the next issue in your inbox.

Every Tuesday. M&A moves, regulatory updates, and exclusive investigations. Free.